Is a boat still a boat if it can’t float?
Recently a company launched a product named Grid that comes from some pretty original thinking of how a spreadsheet can look and function.
Immediately there was a discussion about “Can this product really call itself a spreadsheet? It doesn’t do calculations,” which was pointed a little critically at Grid.
Paul Graham, one of the investors behind Grid said:
The reason I interpreted your question as a snarky one is that it seemed such a pointless one otherwise– like asking, say, whether a boat can be called a boat at a stage so early in its construction that it wouldn’t float.
Actually, I like that question a lot.
Can a boat still be a boat if it doesn’t float?
But not for the purpose it tried to serve in the above discussion. For the reason that it helps us break down the prejudices and stereotypes we have of the products we use every day.
It’s an incredibly enlightening...